I was so looking forward to these liners! The green and white are not opaque at all!!! In order to get the opacity pictured you would have to let the product dry and go over it MULTIPLE times. These are not the most opaque liners at all! The red also stains! I swatched them and in the 20 minutes I had the red on my hand it stained. I had to scrub my hand with a cleanser to get it off. I'm honestly pretty disappointed. I'm going to continue to try to work with them though because despite not being very opaque, they are all really pretty. While the red and black are matte, the green and white are lovely glitter liners. I believe they probably just need some finessing. I understand most people may not want to fuss with multiple layers though, hence the 2 star rating.